Ice Cream Pie Pre-Orders

Pre-orders are now CLOSED. Pickups are December 22nd-24th.

There will be a limited number of Grab & Go pies available at the storefront, first come first serve!

Ice Cream Pies

Hokey Pokey
$37.00
sold out
Add To Cart
Cookies & Peppermint
$37.00
sold out
Add To Cart
S'mores
$37.00
sold out
Add To Cart
Dairy Free/Vegan Chocolate Peppermint
$42.00
sold out
Add To Cart

FAQs

  • We might be able to accommodate - please email lillie@wellysicecream.com before placing your order with any special requests for the holidays.

  • Not at the time, we only do pies during the holiday season.

  • We will have some extras available in the Grab & Go, but pre-order is the way to go to guarantee you get your hands on a holiday pie.

  • You can request a gluten free crust on some of the pies, the option will be available as a drop-down. No extra cost.

  • Yes, the ice cream and toppings used on the Dairy Free Chocolate Pie is vegan. The ice cream and whipped topping is oat milk based.